FCC deals a blow to T-Mobile and SpaceX's satellite ambitions but there's still hope
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase from the links on this page.
Update: An earlier version of this story incorrectly stated that the FCC has finalized its decision to not grant a waiver to SpaceX. It has been updated to reflect the correct information, which is that nothing can be decided until after August 29.
The error is regretted.
The original story continues below.
###
In a new report that states the current rules for the deployment of supplemental coverage from space (SCS), the FCC has laid down its technical requirements. According to the rules, there won't be any relaxation on the power flux density limit of -120 dBW/m2 /MHz.
SpaceX was hoping for up to a ninefold increase to the limit, but the suggestion was met by opposition from AT&T, Verizon, EchoStar, and Omnispace, all of whom said that a relaxed out-of-band PFD would cause interference with their networks.
At the forefront of the argument was the point that like its rivals, T-Mobile also "has terrestrial operations in frequency bands that are adjacent to those in which SpaceX will operate," which is why it's equally paramount for the carrier to ensure satellite transmissions do not impact its operations.
The company holds the majority of the licenses for the C Block PCS spectrum, the upper band edge of which is directly adjacent to the spectrum that SpaceX will use to transmit signals for satellites. AT&T and Verizon, on the other hand, have significantly fewer licenses.
T-Mobile argued that SpaceX has demonstrated that its operations would protect adjacent-band operations and their competitors are overstating the importance of a conservative limit to delay the rollout of their direct-to-cellular service.
The company also said that SpaceX would not be able to offer robust satellite coverage if the FCC didn't relax its requirements. Now that it seems like the FCC is not amenable to SpaceX's suggestions, it's possible that AT&T and Verizon will deploy their satellite services before T-Mobile, while SpaceX works through the FCC's requirements.
T-Mobile argued that SpaceX has demonstrated that its operations would protect adjacent-band operations and their competitors are overstating the importance of a conservative limit to delay the rollout of their direct-to-cellular service.
The company also said that SpaceX would not be able to offer robust satellite coverage if the FCC didn't relax its requirements. Now that it seems like the FCC is not amenable to SpaceX's suggestions, it's possible that AT&T and Verizon will deploy their satellite services before T-Mobile, while SpaceX works through the FCC's requirements.
The FCC is not expected to reach a final decision before August 29.
FCC OKs Cingular\'s purchase of AT&T Wireless
Things that are NOT allowed: