Debate: Do we still need а headphone jack on our phones?

Join the discussion
Crispin_Gatieza
Crispin_Gatieza
Arena Master
• 1y ago
↵MariyanSlavov said:

I was a firm supporter of the headphone jack for many years, but lately I've been using it less and less often... Of course, it's better to have it and not need it than vice versa... Wireless headphones have one huge issue for me - battery life. Another gadget to charge and think about...

Better to have it and not need it…….that’s always been my argument for the 9mm.


As for the topic at hand, we don’t NEED the wired connection but it’s infinitely better. If you’ve owned a higher end LG phone then you know what I mean, the sound quality is night and day compared to Bluetooth. Anyone who says it doesn’t really matter, that’s fine. Just never write a review about a phone and complain that the audio is not that good, it doesn’t really matter right?

Like
8
Quote
ullokey
ullokey
Arena Apprentice
• 1y ago
↵MariyanSlavov said:

So, Apple was right to remove the jack back in 2016? :) :) :)

I thought Motorola removed it way back with their Moto Z

Like
1
Quote
jjface
jjface
Arena Apprentice
• 1y agoedited

Y E S

Duh

Like
6
Quote
ibap
ibap
Arena Apprentice
• 1y ago

Yes we do.


It won't take just typing yes. Needs 5 characters.

Like
6
Quote
eyeflaps
eyeflaps
Arena Apprentice
• 1y agoedited

Yes. I won't buy a phone unless it has one. Companies like apple and Samsung need to stop "innovating" by removing features. They removed the headphone jack and called it innovation so people could use lighting/usbC headphones instead. Stupid. Now the spot where the headphone jack used to be is a smooth flat surface. They could have put it there anyways. It's pointless. Stop buying phones without.

Like
7
Quote
Brewski
Brewski
Arena Master
• 1y ago
↵ullokey said:

I thought Motorola removed it way back with their Moto Z

Yup. I had that phone, and then a few months later the iPhone X came out. But when Apple did it, it was B O L D

Like
Quote
Takeharu
Takeharu
Arena Apprentice
• 1y ago
↵ullokey said:

I thought Motorola removed it way back with their Moto Z

Nintendo removed it all the way back with the Gameboy Advance SP

Like
Quote
Panino
Panino
Arena Apprentice
• 1y ago

Definitely missing it. As someone who makes a lot of phone calls, no Bluetooth headset can match the microphone sound quality of wired headphones. Sure, Type C wired headphones exist, but it's convenient to be able to charge the phone while continuing to make calls using wired headphones.

Like
4
Quote
Takeharu
Takeharu
Arena Apprentice
• 1y agoedited

Not gonna lie, I hated wireless headphones at first. I am not exactly an audiophile but I do care a lot about good sounding audio and I'm not afraid to pay for it. I was using Westone and Shure IEM's all the way until I got my Note 20 Ultra in 2020, my first phone without a headphone jack. I was stubborn and kept using wired headphones with a dongle but the inconvenience grew bigger and bigger. Forgetting the dongle, losing it and the biggest one: not being able to charge and listen to music at the same time.


I finally caved in 2021 and truth be told it has been surprisingly fine. Sure wireless doesn't sound as good as wired but it's fine. I'm not doing critical listening anyway when I'm on the move. Charging isn't really a problem for me so yeah.


I still wish it were an option though so we could chose

Like
Quote
MikeManic
MikeManic
Arena Apprentice
• 1y agoedited

Let's weigh the pros and cons of this topic.

Pros for the Aux Jack:

3.5mm Aux cord headphones are price effective

Better quality from wired headphones

Never need to charge the headphones

Can still charge your phone while having your headphones plugged in

3.5mm Adapters exist for studio grade headphones


Pros for not having the Jack:

1 less hole for water to get into the phone

No wires to worry about getting tangled

The 3.5mm hole limited how thin/light/sleek the phone could get

Batteries can be larger without the 3.5mm jack


Honestly, I'd settle for a using another port (Like another C-Type) to plug your headphones into, not only to listen to your music/call, but also charge the headphones at the same time. So a Phone would have 2 USB Type-C ports, or 2 Lightning ports (For Apple's closed ecosystem). Listen to music, while charging the headphones, and charging the phone. All at the same time. Win Win in my book.

Like
3
Quote
FCC OKs Cingular\'s purchase of AT&T Wireless