Jury rules in Google's favor, says Android's use of Oracle's Java APIs covered by fair use doctrine

47comments
Jury rules in Google's favor, says Android's use of Oracle's Java APIs covered by fair use doctrine
A jury ruled this afternoon in favor of Google in a lawsuit filed by Oracle against the search giant. Oracle claimed that without permission, Google  copied more than 37 Java APIs, and 11 lines of Java source code for the open source Android operating system. Oracle originally brought a similar suit against Google back in 2010. During that trial, Google said that APIs cannot receive copyright protection, and that its use of Java was covered under the doctrine of fair use. The judge agreed, and in May 2012 the case was dismissed. The judge's ruling essentially rubber stamped what the jury concluded.

Oracle won its appeal, and the case was remanded back to district court where Oracle sought $9.3 billion from Google. All that the case could have been about was money, since Google had already announced in December that starting with Android N, it would be replacing Java with OpenJDK. That happens to be the open source version of Java. Using it would allow Google to employ Java for Android without requiring permission from Oracle.

With Google's victory another win for its 'fair use' theory, Oracle could have decided to walk away and call it a day. Instead, the company says that it will appeal the jury's decision. Under the doctrine of fair use, unlicensed use of copyrighted material is permitted under certain circumstances.

source: TechCrunch
Create a free account and join our vibrant community
Register to enjoy the full PhoneArena experience. Here’s what you get with your PhoneArena account:
  • Access members-only articles
  • Join community discussions
  • Share your own device reviews
  • Build your personal phone library
Register For Free

Recommended Stories

Loading Comments...
FCC OKs Cingular\'s purchase of AT&T Wireless